A colleague recently sent this article link around for us to have a squiz at a couple of weeks ago. I found it incredibly interesting, especially as I had just switched the method of recording my student's reading time. I just wanted to record what I had tried, my anecdotal notes on the subject and my thoughts around using rewards in a reading programme. (stay with my I get to my thoughts on the article at the end)
Last year I stumbled upon Bookopolis. Here are the things I was drawn to and enjoyed using it for with my students:
- I could see what my students were reading: great for understanding just what interests them when they are reading at home.
- I could recommend books to them: I could see what they were reading and suggest similar authors
- Students could see what each other were reading: they could also recommend books to each other.
- Students could complete book reviews, book buzzes (mini reviews), recommendations and reports: no more trying to get them to review the books I was giving them, they could tell me about literature they were truly interested in.
- Students could log their reading time and date.
As you can see when I began using this with my students I wasn't at all interested in the badges. In fact, when I noticed them I thought they were a nice bonus. My students however, thought nothing much of them. Sure, they thought they were cool at first, but the reviewing and putting books in their library was much more engaging than earning badges, especially when the badges weren't really good for anything.
ENTER CLASS OF 2016
Now here's the funny thing, (and this will continue to amuse me for every year that I teach) just because something worked with, or was picked up and loved by, a previous class, in no way indicates that the next class will too. I'm not sure why, of course I understand about different personalities and learning styles etc, maybe it was the way or the time of year that I introduced it, but Bookopolis certainly didn't take off with this year's bunch. One major difference was I began by using it purely as a reading log tool. My plan was to eventually make use of the book review and reporting tools as they became more familiar with it, but alas that day never came. Week after week I logged in to find that no more than 5 students at most had logged their reading homework. Student's were becoming frustrated with it, parents couldn't figure it out and the dates (being American) were wrong the majority of the time rendering my best laid plans for check their reading minutes each week, in tatters. By the end of Term 1 I was ready to give up and almost went back to the old way of recording reading but I thought there must be another, more user friendly version of an online reading log. There was.
ENTER READING REWARDS (reading-rewards.com)
What a success! Reading-rewards and another site called Biblionasium were only two of many more sites I found, but these had the most similar features to Bookopolis. I trialled both of them with my top reading groups and quickly found the most preferred logging method. All the students agreed that reading-rewards was the easiest to use and they even enjoyed being able to record what books they had been reading. HOORAY! Since then I have indeed been able to see exactly how much my students have been reading each week and what they have been reading. Soon I hope to engage them with the reward functions and the reading challenges which I suppose is what the article above is suggesting against. I have several thoughts on the matter from my observations.
#1 The whole aim of reading homework and encouraging and recording reading is to ensure reading mileage. You don't get better at reading by not reading and reading a lot is better than reading a little. It's the same with maths. Practising basic facts each night is better than not and when we introduced rote practice of this into our homework cycle we saw huge improvements in our students' basic fact scores and in turn their strategy work improved. If a student has the knowledge to complete a task the task becomes easy, if a student knows their basic facts they can use them to solve larger problems. If a student knows how read and engage with a text, they will be able to use this when reading to learn or understand in all areas of the curriculum. So in short, reading mileage is great and much needed.
#2 Yes, I absolutely agree that we need to encourage and foster a love for reading in itself and not just as a way to earn points. However, I have two sub thoughts on this. a) Some students actually need to be encouraged to read as a chore because they may not enjoy reading as much as something else they could be doing, here is where incentives really work, and because the child is working towards something, sometimes that is enough to help them find the joy in what they are doing. b) Here is where I think it's important to monitor your students' response to incentives. If the incentive is taking over, and the class is resorting to cheating the system then it's probably worth toning the incentives down a bit.
#3 Incentives exist in real life. When you leave school, study, get a job there are incentives all around us. We have incentives in our job to work hard, including the stuff we'd rather not do, as this will lead to promotion and a pay rise. We even create our own incentives, I know I often told myself I could watch an episode of my favourite TV show if I could just get 500 words written in my essay. Even now I tell myself I can surf Facebook AFTER I've done those dishes, then I need to do the washing and I can read my book!
In conclusion, I can definitely see the downside to having badges for something like reading. This year though, I'm going to give it a go and monitor my students' response to it, engagement, achievement, attitude, etc. After seeing my students' response to other incentivised learning programmes I hope it can be a great way to open up reading to some of my more reluctant readers and encourage those who love it already. If not, I'm always up for trying something else that does connect with my constantly diverse range of learners!