Saturday, 25 February 2017

Mindlab Assignment: Leadership #1

The next paper in my certificate is called Leadership in Digital and Collaborative Learning. 

For this first assignment we had to: Critically Analyse the leadership of a change intiative you were involved with. Identify the leadership theories, styles and attributes used and evaluate their effectiveness.

I chose to write about how I moved the year 4 team from a single cell to a team teaching approach within a modern learning environment.

Leadership 1
Emily Bagrie

A change initiative I was involved in recently has been a defining moment in my career and continues to be a journey of self-discovery and development for me. I was placed in a role that carried with it an official title of ‘Team Leader’ and within that was tasked with introducing a new collaborative style of teaching. Initially, I followed examples of leadership set for me by the executive leadership at my school, as well as fellow Team Leaders. As I got to know my team their style of followership along with the different skills and personalities they possessed played a huge part in determining my leadership style.

To begin with, I was heavily influenced by the leadership styles and theories carried by those in leadership both above and around me. The Principal of our school demonstrates a leadership style which is characterised by his vision for the school and his ability to involve others in the decision making and outworking of that vision. He also encourages and inspires his staff to develop their passions and seeks to recognise and utilise these. According to Goleman (2000) this style would best be described as a combination of Democratic and Visionary. The Head of the Primary School had a similiar style to this however his included elements of Coaching. Goleman (2000) states that the modus operandi of this leader is to develop people for the future which the Head did by challenging and pushing his staff to try new things, especially new things outside of their comfort zone. When I began my role in leadership these leadership styles impacted me in several ways. Firstly, these leaders had a vision that I had wholeheartedly bought into. I was willing to lead my team into a collaborative and blended style of teaching, a new change initiative, not attempted on this scale with this age group before. Secondly, I felt challenged to push past my comfort zone in order to develop professionally through this role and gain valuable skills and experience. Lastly, I was inspired by their approach as I sought to understand how to best lead a team myself and was excited by the benefits moving into collaborative teaching would have for our students.

On a practical level, another leader I looked to in this process was the Team Leader of the intermediate team. She had experienced great success in implementing collaborative teaching in her team and as a personal friend I had watched and questioned her with interest throughout her own journey of leadership. Her style was people focused with a large emphasis placed on the staff and students that she worked with. Due to her primary focus on people, I view her leadership style, according to Goleman (2000), as being Affiliative. I admired her ability to create productive working relationships with her whole team by getting to know and understand them individually, creating a culture of communication and both considering and representing their needs in decision making situations. In following her example, I sought to develop cohesion within my team by defining with them the culture and environment we wanted to foster. I also desired to have the same open communication policy and was encouraged by the feedback from one of my team members who said she found being under my leadership “easy, because I was always heard and it’s easy to follow someone who is always wanting to hear what you want to say.” (Z. Vermeulen, personal communication, August 22, 2016)
In leading the change from single cell classes to a collaborative and shared learning space, I was extremely fortunate that the only other teacher in my team had trialed team-teaching at a previous school. This positive prior experience took a lot of the work out of trying to create buy-in to my idea as she already was aware of the benefits and subscribed also to the vision of the leaders above me. What this allowed me to do was run with a Visionary style of leadership without any resistance. A second style of leadership I believe I favoured was also Democratic. Goleman (2000) states that the modus operandi for this particular style is forging consensus through participation and that the key features of this style are collaboration, team leading and communication. My team member recalls that my leadership of the team was “very inclusive, I was included in decisions right down to budgeting.”. However, it is a further comment made by her which leads me to reflect on the origin of this democratic approach. She went on to say that “you didn’t believe in yourself from the start as a leader. It was great to see how you stepped into the role and your confidence increased in making decisions” (Z. Vermeulen, personal communication, August 22, 2016). Upon reflection, I certainly believe that I truly wanted to (and still want to) provide an inclusive environment for my team as demonstrated to me by the leaders above me. Although my confidence has much improved since I became team leader, I do think that a lot of the motivation I had for using a democratic approach was due in part to a lack of confidence in my own ability to make leadership decisions. This is not to say, that now that I have greater belief in myself, I no longer include my team in the decision making process. I think now though, that there is a more balanced and genuine motivation for doing so.

The leadership theory that I ascribe to as a Christian is that of Jesus Christ in His demonstration of Servant Leadership. Robert K Greenleaf coined the phrase ‘Servant Leadership’ in 1970. He observed that the most effective leaders he had seen were “not necessarily “big” people” and that the most effective he had seen “was a “little” person in the world of affairs.” (Greenleaf, 1977). This reflects biblical thinking around leadership too. In the Bible leaders are encouraged not to lord their leadership over those in their charge, but rather lead by example (1 Peter 5:3, New International Version). When looking to Christ’s example servant leadership is doing “nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit... not looking to your own interests but...to the interests of the others.” (Philippians 2:3-4). In an almost identical sentiment to Greenleaf, Jesus Christ also explains that "whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant.” (Matthew 20:26). Servant leaders “provide vision, gain credibility and trust from followers, and influence others” (Farling et al., 1999 as cited by Stone, Russell and Patterson, 2004). In light of all of this I do believe that I was in part successful in applying these principles to my leadership practice. The other teacher on my team expressed that she had felt empowered by my commitment to her development in allowing her to try things out in her teaching. She admitted she had felt worried about being able to keep up with the digital side of things, but had felt well supported and had learnt a lot. By taking the time to get to know her and her needs, strengths, weaknesses I could see how the vision of collaboration could relate to and grow her as a teacher, not the other way around.
This was all well and good until I came to realise something about my team. There was more than just me and the other teacher. Now, this is not to say that I hadn’t considered my three Learning Assistants as a part of my team. I did however find that I had taken a different approach to leading them and found that the resulting dilemma was teachers and Learning Assistants who were on two different pages. How had this communication blunder appeared? I had attempted to inspire them with my vision on multiple occasions, I had also encouraged them and modeled for them how they might carry this out. From what I have read in Mindtools: Online Management, Leadership and Career Training (2016) these are key features of Transformational Leadership, and can be a very effective way to lead. So why did I still feel we lacked a shared understanding? I came across another article comparing Transformational Leadership with Servant Leadership which highlighted a major difference between the two. Stone, Russell, & Patterson (2004) identified that:
“The primary difference between transformational leadership and servant leadership is the focus of the leader. The transformational leader’s focus is directed toward the organization, and his or her behavior builds follower commitment toward organizational objectives, while the servant leader’s focus is on the followers, and the achievement of organizational objectives is a subordinate outcome.”

I would argue that this is the weakness of Transformational Leadership and a strength of Servant Leadership. When your focus is on people you are able to see where their next steps are, what support they require and are able to push them forward in their own career journey. This in turn creates satisfied and more productive team members who are willing and more able to carry out the vision as supported by McMinn (2001 as cited by Stone, Russell and Patterson, 2004) who states that “Servant leaders develop people, helping them to strive and flourish”. In collaborative teaching I believe that this may be even more vital. Through knowing exactly where my team is both personally and professionally I know where to pick up the slack, what opportunities they may be lacking and what support they may need. I do not wish to throw the baby out with the bathwater however, and believe that the Blake Mouton Managerial Grid demonstrates a harmony between the key features of these leadership theories. When concern for people and concern for the task or vision are both equally as high, this brings about Team Management which results in staff being involved closely in decision making and feeling valued. (“Leadership Styles - Blake Mouton Managerial Grid,” 2015)

This reflective essay has enabled me to critique my approach to leading this change initiative and how I can do better going forward. It has been easy to work in partnership with the other teacher in my team, as I have been able to get to know her well enough to identify how I might best serve her within the leadership context. However, I believe I have neglected to do this as well with the Learning Assistants in my team. Ultimately, although I was passionate about proving myself as a leader and doing something innovative within my team, it is all pointless unless I am developing and supporting the people that I work with. Not only for the sake of the vision but because “The servant leader’s primary objective is to serve and meet the needs of others” (Russell and Stone, 2002, as cited by Stone, Russell and Patterson, 2004). It is as the Maori Proverb goes: He aha te mea nui o te ao, He tangata, he tangata, he tangata (What is the most important thing in the world? It is the people, it is the people, it is the people).

REFERENCES

Blake, R. R., Mouton, J. S., & Bidwell, A. C. (1962). Managerial grid. Advanced Management-Office Executive.

Greenleaf, R. K. (1977). Servant leadership.

Goleman, D. (2000). Leadership that gets results. Leadership Styles - Blake Mouton Managerial Grid. (2015). Retrieved from http://www.tutor2u.net/business/reference/lead ership-styles-blake-mouton-managerial-grid
Mind Tools: Online Management, Leadership and Career Training. (2016). Mindtools.com. Retrieved 11 August 2016, from http://www.mindtools.com

Gregory Stone, A., Russell, R. F., & Patterson, K. (2004). Transformational versus servant leadership: A difference in leader focus. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 25(4), 349-361.

Vermeulen, Z. (2016, August 22). Personal interview.

No comments:

Post a Comment