Ethical dilemmas, it's something we studied back in teacher's college, part of the Professional Teacher paper I believe, and a particularly juicy and confusing topic to wade through. As much as you are prepared there is something to be said for on the job training. Through your own experiences or from watching your colleagues deal with the twists and turns of navigating teaching and all that brings with it. From parent to student to staff interactions, you build up a repertoire of strategies similar to those referred to by Hall (2001) and prevention measures as identified and advised to employ in the Digital Technology Guide For Schools (Ministry of Education, 2015).
A couple of years ago, when BYOD was first introduced at our school, we were faced with an incident involving said devices being used to access inappropriate content, in the bathroom no less! This was a new thing for us, not only did we not consider nor prepare ourselves for the fact that our students might do such a thing, but we were completely unprepared for how to respond. We had a behaviour management system, but that involved behaviour that was physical or verbal, nothing was in place around our students conduct involving digital devices. We had and still have a "Responsible Cyber Citizen Agreement" which clearly outlines the dos and don'ts around the use of devices. It even mentions the possibility of suspension or being stood down for breaching these. However, where did we stand on our ability to search, delete and confiscate a student device and what consequences and proactive measure could we put in place to try and prevent it from happening again?
Answering a mix of the questions used by Hall (2001) and the Ethical and Professional Dilemmas for Educators: Facilitator’s Guide (2012) I will unpack this situation and its potential solutions and repercussions.
What is the problem? What possible issues/concerns might this scenario raise?
How could this situation become a violation of the law, the “Code” or other school /district policies?
In this situation, what are some potential negative consequences for the teacher, for the students and the school community?
Obviously in this scenario the first problem is that the students have broken the code of conduct with their device. They weren't accessing content for 'the purposes of advancing their education' (at least not in a way that was appropriate!). But the problem goes further than just the misuse of the device. The content was exposed to a group of other students, which brings into question the emotional and potentially even physical safety of students. The content was accessed on the school's network which brings into question the filtering and blocking software installed. Also, as a worst case scenario, it was unknown at that stage if the content was illegal or just restricted which could lead to legal action needing to be taken.
Who are the main stakeholders and what are their interests?
Which stakeholder should be given priority?
a) The students involved have been exposed to inappropriate content.
b) The parents of the students who have entrusted the safety and wellbeing of their children to the school, including protections and supervisions around the internet and use of the iPad while at school.
c) The students not involved who are are risk of being exposed to inappropriate content on the school's network.
What restrictions are there to your actions?
No policy at that stage existed which outlined the consequences for iPad misuse, could we take the iPad off them, they were personally owned devices so this was unclear. There was the issue of parent privacy and autonomy over these devices. However, at the same time the Code of Ethics states that as teachers we must exercise "Responsible care to do good and minimise harm to others".
Which courses of action are possible?
a) Seize the device and search it's content for evidence of inappropriate content.
b) Ask the student to reveal/delete the content.
c) Confiscate the device and contact the parents of the students involved, decide on consequences for this particular case and ensure counselling is given if required.
d) Relook at the school's network and filtering software as well as its policy around iPad misuse. Put prevention measures in place and policies around consequences of misuse.
Which courses of action are least acceptable?
a) is not acceptable as the Digital Technology Guide For Schools (Ministry of Education, 2015) states searching can do more harm than good and open teachers up to being accused of tampering, break a chain of evidence or even infringe on parent rights.
b) is not acceptable as the content may or may not be deletable, and does not address the issue at hand which is the accessing of content in the first place, it does not acknowledge this impact this may have already have and the necessity to prevent it from happening again.
Which course of action will you follow? How should the course be implemented?
What responses/actions will result in a more positive outcome and/or what proactive measures might be considered?
C and D are the most acceptable courses of action and provide a double barrelled approach to solving the problem. From memory this is what was done and the outcome of this has meant we haven't had this situation recur. Firstly, the student's iPad was confiscated until it could be retrieved by the parent. The parents of all students were notified and counselling was made available. The school network was relooked at and filtering, monitoring and blocking was upgraded. School policy was amended to include a consequence system for serious iPad misuse, iPad's would be confiscated until parent's collected them and their return to school would be considered on a case by case basis. In terms of my own classroom practice I made several amendments: I ensured we had a comprehensive digital citizenship and safety focus at the start of each year, this involved converting the very wordy Cyber Citizen Agreement into a student friendly version. Students had to pass a 'licence' test which ensured they understood when and how they could use their iPad at school. I also introduced a strike system for those breaking these minor rules (as opposed to serious misuse). A strike system was implemented where students would lose their iPad for the day for each of the first two strikes and for a week, along with parental involvement, upon receiving their third.
What does the incident teach about ethical decision-making?
I believe this particular incident shows that it is important to consider as many 'worst-case-scenarios' as possible when setting up or introducing new ways of learning or working. I am sure that had we sat down and hashed some of these out we would have been ready for what we dealt with and I'm sure that even by talking to others who had already been implementing BYOD we could glean some excellent pearls of wisdom in this area. Overall though, it has been encouraging to see how this scenario played out and how things were improved as a result of reflection and adjustment.
References
Connecticut’s Teacher Education and Mentoring Program. (2012). Ethical and Professional Dilemmas for Educators: Facilitator’s Guide. Retrieved from http://www.ctteam.org/df/resources/Module5_Manual....
Education Council. (n.d). The Education Council Code of Ethics for Certificated Teachers. Retrieved from https://educationcouncil.org.nz/content/code-of-et...
Hall, A. (2001). What ought I to do, all things considered? An approach to the exploration of ethical problems by teachers. Paper presented at the IIPE Conference, Brisbane. Retrieved from http://www.educationalleaders.govt.nz/Culture/Developing-leaders/What-Ought-I-to-Do-All-Things-Considered-An-Approach-to-the-Exploration-of-Ethical-Problems-by-Teachers
Ministry of Education. (2015). Digital technology - Safe and responsible use in schools. Retrieved from http://www.education.govt.nz/assets/Documents/School/Managing-and-supporting-students/DigitalTechnologySafeAndResponsibleUseInSchs.pdf
No comments:
Post a Comment